what is property-µÚ78ÕÂ
°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡û »ò ¡ú ¿É¿ìËÙÉÏÏ·ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉ쵀 Enter ¼ü¿É»Øµ½±¾ÊéĿ¼ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡ü ¿É»Øµ½±¾Ò³¶¥²¿£¡
¡ª¡ª¡ª¡ªÎ´ÔĶÁÍꣿ¼ÓÈëÊéÇ©ÒѱãÏ´μÌÐøÔĶÁ£¡
aud£»¡¡and¡¡cowards¡¡to¡¡offer¡¡me¡¡the¡¡dictatorship£»¡¡for£»¡¡in¡¡the¡¡way¡¡of¡¡popular¡¡infatuations£»¡¡nothing¡¡is¡¡impossible¡£
But£»¡¡sir£»¡¡after¡¡this¡¡monument¡¡of¡¡insolence¡¡and¡¡pride£»¡¡what¡¡should¡¡I¡¡have¡¡deserved¡¡in¡¡your¡¡opinion£»¡¡at¡¡the¡¡tribunal¡¡of¡¡God£»¡¡and¡¡in¡¡the¡¡judgment¡¡of¡¡free¡¡men£¿¡¡¡¡Death£»¡¡sir£»¡¡and¡¡eternal¡¡reprobation£¡
I¡¡therefore¡¡spoke¡¡the¡¡truth¡¡as¡¡soon¡¡as¡¡I¡¡saw¡¡it£»¡¡waiting¡¡only¡¡long¡¡enough¡¡to¡¡give¡¡it¡¡proper¡¡expression¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡pointed¡¡out¡¡error¡¡in¡¡order¡¡that¡¡each¡¡might¡¡reform¡¡himself£»¡¡and¡¡render¡¡his¡¡labors¡¡more¡¡useful¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡announced¡¡the¡¡existence¡¡of¡¡a¡¡new¡¡political¡¡element£»¡¡in¡¡order¡¡that¡¡my¡¡associates¡¡in¡¡reform£»¡¡developing¡¡it¡¡in¡¡concert£»¡¡might¡¡arrive¡¡more¡¡promptly¡¡at¡¡that¡¡unity¡¡of¡¡principles¡¡which¡¡alone¡¡can¡¡assure¡¡to¡¡society¡¡a¡¡better¡¡day¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡expected¡¡to¡¡receive£»¡¡if¡¡not¡¡for¡¡my¡¡book£»¡¡at¡¡least¡¡for¡¡my¡¡commendable¡¡conduct£»¡¡a¡¡small¡¡republican¡¡ovation¡£¡¡¡¡And£»¡¡behold£¡¡¡journalists¡¡denounce¡¡me£»¡¡academicians¡¡curse¡¡me£»¡¡political¡¡adventurers¡¡£¨great¡¡God£¡£©¡¡think¡¡to¡¡make¡¡themselves¡¡tolerable¡¡by¡¡protesting¡¡that¡¡they¡¡are¡¡not¡¡like¡¡me£¡¡¡¡¡I¡¡give¡¡the¡¡formula¡¡by¡¡which¡¡the¡¡whole¡¡social¡¡edifice¡¡may¡¡be¡¡scientifically¡¡reconstructed£»¡¡and¡¡the¡¡strongest¡¡minds¡¡reproach¡¡me¡¡for¡¡being¡¡able¡¡only¡¡to¡¡destroy¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡rest¡¡despise¡¡me£»¡¡because¡¡I¡¡am¡¡unknown¡£¡¡¡¡When¡¡the¡¡¡¨Essay¡¡on¡¡Property¡¨¡¡fell¡¡into¡¡the¡¡reformatory¡¡camp£»¡¡some¡¡asked£º¡¡¡¡¡¨Who¡¡has¡¡spoken£¿¡¡¡¡Is¡¡it¡¡Arago£¿¡¡¡¡Is¡¡it¡¡Lamennais£¿¡¡¡¡Michel¡¡de¡¡Bourges¡¡or¡¡Garnier¡Pages£¿¡¨
And¡¡when¡¡they¡¡heard¡¡the¡¡name¡¡of¡¡a¡¡new¡¡man£º¡¡¡¡¡¨We¡¡do¡¡not¡¡know¡¡him£»¡¨¡¡they¡¡would¡¡reply¡£¡¡¡¡Thus£»¡¡the¡¡monopoly¡¡of¡¡thought£»¡¡property¡¡in¡¡reason£»¡¡oppresses¡¡the¡¡proletariat¡¡as¡¡well¡¡as¡¡the¡¡_bourgeoisie_¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡worship¡¡of¡¡the¡¡infamous¡¡prevails¡¡even¡¡on¡¡the¡¡steps¡¡of¡¡the¡¡tabernacle¡£
But¡¡what¡¡am¡¡I¡¡saying£¿¡¡¡¡May¡¡evil¡¡befall¡¡me£»¡¡if¡¡I¡¡blame¡¡the¡¡poor¡¡creatures£¡¡¡¡¡Oh£¡¡¡let¡¡us¡¡not¡¡despise¡¡those¡¡generous¡¡souls£»¡¡who¡¡in¡¡the¡¡excitement¡¡of¡¡their¡¡patriotism¡¡are¡¡always¡¡prompt¡¡to¡¡identify¡¡the¡¡voice¡¡of¡¡their¡¡chiefs¡¡with¡¡the¡¡truth¡£¡¡¡¡Let¡¡us¡¡encourage¡¡rather¡¡their¡¡simple¡¡credulity£»¡¡enlighten¡¡complacently¡¡and¡¡tenderly¡¡their¡¡precious¡¡sincerity£»¡¡and¡¡reserve¡¡our¡¡shafts¡¡for¡¡those¡¡vain¡glorious¡¡spirits¡¡who¡¡are¡¡always¡¡admiring¡¡their¡¡genius£»¡¡and£»¡¡in¡¡different¡¡tongues£»¡¡caressing¡¡the¡¡people¡¡in¡¡order¡¡to¡¡govern¡¡them¡£
These¡¡considerations¡¡alone¡¡oblige¡¡me¡¡to¡¡reply¡¡to¡¡the¡¡strange¡¡and¡¡superficial¡¡conclusions¡¡of¡¡the¡¡¡¨Journal¡¡du¡¡Peuple¡¨¡¡£¨issue¡¡of¡¡Oct¡£¡¡11£»¡¡1840£©£»¡¡on¡¡the¡¡question¡¡of¡¡property¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡leave£»¡¡therefore£»¡¡the¡¡journalist¡¡to¡¡address¡¡myself¡¡only¡¡to¡¡his¡¡readers¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡hope¡¡that¡¡the¡¡self¡love¡¡of¡¡the¡¡writer¡¡will¡¡not¡¡be¡¡offended£»¡¡if£»¡¡in¡¡the¡¡presence¡¡of¡¡the¡¡masses£»¡¡I¡¡ignore¡¡an¡¡individual¡£
You¡¡say£»¡¡proletaires¡¡of¡¡the¡¡¡¨Peuple£»¡¨¡¡¡¨For¡¡the¡¡very¡¡reason¡¡that¡¡men¡¡and¡¡things¡¡exist£»¡¡there¡¡always¡¡will¡¡be¡¡men¡¡who¡¡will¡¡possess¡¡things£»¡¡nothing£»¡¡therefore£»¡¡can¡¡destroy¡¡property¡£¡¨
In¡¡speaking¡¡thus£»¡¡you¡¡unconsciously¡¡argue¡¡exactly¡¡after¡¡the¡¡manner¡¡of¡¡M¡£¡¡Cousin£»¡¡who¡¡always¡¡reasons¡¡from¡¡_possession_¡¡to¡¡PROPERTY¡£¡¡¡¡This¡¡coincidence£»¡¡however£»¡¡does¡¡not¡¡surprise¡¡me¡£¡¡¡¡M¡£¡¡Cousin¡¡is¡¡a¡¡philosopher¡¡of¡¡much¡¡mind£»¡¡and¡¡you£»¡¡proletaires£»¡¡have¡¡still¡¡more¡£¡¡¡¡Certainly¡¡it¡¡is¡¡honorable£»¡¡even¡¡for¡¡a¡¡philosopher£»¡¡to¡¡be¡¡your¡¡companion¡¡in¡¡error¡£
Originally£»¡¡the¡¡word¡¡PROPERTY¡¡was¡¡synonymous¡¡with¡¡PROPER¡¡or¡¡INDIVIDUAL¡¡POSSESSION¡£¡¡¡¡It¡¡designated¡¡each¡¡individual's¡¡special¡¡right¡¡to¡¡the¡¡use¡¡of¡¡a¡¡thing¡£¡¡¡¡But¡¡when¡¡this¡¡right¡¡of¡¡use£»¡¡inert¡¡£¨if¡¡I¡¡may¡¡say¡¡so£©¡¡as¡¡it¡¡was¡¡with¡¡regard¡¡to¡¡the¡¡other¡¡usufructuaries£»¡¡became¡¡active¡¡and¡¡paramount£»that¡¡is£»¡¡when¡¡the¡¡usufructuary¡¡converted¡¡his¡¡right¡¡to¡¡personally¡¡use¡¡the¡¡thing¡¡into¡¡the¡¡right¡¡to¡¡use¡¡it¡¡by¡¡his¡¡neighbor's¡¡labor£»then¡¡property¡¡changed¡¡its¡¡nature£»¡¡and¡¡its¡¡idea¡¡became¡¡complex¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡legists¡¡knew¡¡this¡¡very¡¡well£»¡¡but¡¡instead¡¡of¡¡opposing£»¡¡as¡¡they¡¡ought£»¡¡this¡¡accumulation¡¡of¡¡profits£»¡¡they¡¡accepted¡¡and¡¡sanctioned¡¡the¡¡whole¡£¡¡¡¡And¡¡as¡¡the¡¡right¡¡of¡¡farm¡rent¡¡necessarily¡¡implies¡¡the¡¡right¡¡of¡¡use£»in¡¡other¡¡words£»¡¡as¡¡the¡¡right¡¡to¡¡cultivate¡¡land¡¡by¡¡the¡¡labor¡¡of¡¡a¡¡slave¡¡supposes¡¡one's¡¡power¡¡to¡¡cultivate¡¡it¡¡himself£»¡¡according¡¡to¡¡the¡¡principle¡¡that¡¡the¡¡greater¡¡includes¡¡the¡¡less£»¡¡the¡¡name¡¡property¡¡was¡¡reserved¡¡to¡¡designate¡¡this¡¡double¡¡right£»¡¡and¡¡that¡¡of¡¡possession¡¡was¡¡adopted¡¡to¡¡designate¡¡the¡¡right¡¡of¡¡use¡£
Whence¡¡property¡¡came¡¡to¡¡be¡¡called¡¡the¡¡perfect¡¡right£»¡¡the¡¡right¡¡of¡¡domain£»¡¡the¡¡eminent¡¡right£»¡¡the¡¡heroic¡¡or¡¡_quiritaire_¡¡right£»in¡¡Latin£»¡¡_jus¡¡perfectum£»¡¡jus¡¡optimum£»¡¡jus¡¡quiritarium£»¡¡jus¡¡dominii_£»while¡¡possession¡¡became¡¡assimilated¡¡to¡¡farm¡rent¡£
Now£»¡¡that¡¡individual¡¡possession¡¡exists¡¡of¡¡right£»¡¡or£»¡¡better£»¡¡from¡¡natural¡¡necessity£»¡¡all¡¡philosophers¡¡admit£»¡¡and¡¡can¡¡easily¡¡e¡¡demonstrated£»¡¡but¡¡when£»¡¡in¡¡imitation¡¡of¡¡M¡£¡¡Cousin£»¡¡we¡¡assume¡¡it¡¡to¡¡be¡¡the¡¡basis¡¡of¡¡the¡¡domain¡¡of¡¡property£»¡¡we¡¡fall¡¡into¡¡the¡¡sophism¡¡called¡¡_sophisma¡¡amphiboliae¡¡vel¡¡ambiguitatis_£»¡¡which¡¡consists¡¡in¡¡changing¡¡the¡¡meaning¡¡by¡¡a¡¡verbal¡¡equivocation¡£
People¡¡often¡¡think¡¡themselves¡¡very¡¡profound£»¡¡because£»¡¡by¡¡the¡¡aid¡¡of¡¡expressions¡¡of¡¡extreme¡¡generality£»¡¡they¡¡appear¡¡to¡¡rise¡¡to¡¡the¡¡height¡¡of¡¡absolute¡¡ideas£»¡¡and¡¡thus¡¡deceive¡¡inexperienced¡¡minds£»¡¡and£»¡¡what¡¡is¡¡worse£»¡¡this¡¡is¡¡commonly¡¡called¡¡EXAMINING¡¡ABSTRACTIONS¡£¡¡¡¡But¡¡the¡¡abstraction¡¡formed¡¡by¡¡the¡¡comparison¡¡of¡¡identical¡¡facts¡¡is¡¡one¡¡thing£»¡¡while¡¡that¡¡which¡¡is¡¡deduced¡¡from¡¡different¡¡acceptations¡¡of¡¡the¡¡same¡¡term¡¡is¡¡quite¡¡another¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡first¡¡gives¡¡the¡¡universal¡¡idea£»¡¡the¡¡axiom£»¡¡the¡¡law£»¡¡the¡¡second¡¡indicates¡¡the¡¡order¡¡of¡¡generation¡¡of¡¡ideas¡£¡¡¡¡All¡¡our¡¡errors¡¡arise¡¡from¡¡the¡¡constant¡¡confusion¡¡of¡¡these¡¡two¡¡kinds¡¡of¡¡abstractions¡£¡¡¡¡In¡¡this¡¡particular£»¡¡languages¡¡and¡¡philosophies¡¡are¡¡alike¡¡deficient¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡less¡¡common¡¡an¡¡idiom¡¡is£»¡¡and¡¡the¡¡more¡¡obscure¡¡its¡¡terms£»¡¡the¡¡more¡¡prolific¡¡is¡¡it¡¡as¡¡a¡¡source¡¡of¡¡error£º¡¡a¡¡philosopher¡¡is¡¡sophistical¡¡in¡¡proportion¡¡to¡¡his¡¡ignorance¡¡of¡¡any¡¡method¡¡of¡¡neutralizing¡¡this¡¡imperfection¡¡in¡¡language¡£¡¡¡¡If¡¡the¡¡art¡¡of¡¡correcting¡¡the¡¡errors¡¡of¡¡speech¡¡by¡¡scientific¡¡methods¡¡is¡¡ever¡¡discovered£»¡¡then¡¡philosophy¡¡will¡¡have¡¡found¡¡its¡¡criterion¡¡of¡¡certainty¡£
Now£»¡¡then£»¡¡the¡¡difference¡¡between¡¡property¡¡and¡¡possession¡¡being¡¡well¡¡established£»¡¡and¡¡it¡¡being¡¡settled¡¡that¡¡the¡¡former£»¡¡for¡¡the¡¡reasons¡¡which¡¡I¡¡have¡¡just¡¡given£»¡¡must¡¡necessarily¡¡disappear£»¡¡is¡¡it¡¡best£»¡¡for¡¡the¡¡slight¡¡advantage¡¡of¡¡restoring¡¡an¡¡etymology£»¡¡to¡¡retain¡¡the¡¡word¡¡PROPERTY£¿¡¡¡¡My¡¡opinion¡¡is¡¡that¡¡it¡¡would¡¡be¡¡very¡¡unwise¡¡to¡¡do¡¡so£»¡¡and¡¡I¡¡will¡¡tell¡¡why¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡quote¡¡from¡¡the¡¡¡¨Journal¡¡du¡¡Peuple£º¡¨
¡¨To¡¡the¡¡legislative¡¡power¡¡belongs¡¡the¡¡right¡¡to¡¡regulate¡¡property£»¡¡to¡¡prescribe¡¡the¡¡conditions¡¡of¡¡acquiring£»¡¡possessing£»¡¡and¡¡transmitting¡¡it¡£¡¡¡£¡¡¡£¡¡¡¡It¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡denied¡¡that¡¡inheritance£»¡¡assessment£»¡¡commerce£»¡¡industry£»¡¡labor£»¡¡and¡¡wages¡¡require¡¡the¡¡most¡¡important¡¡modifications¡£¡¨
You¡¡wish£»¡¡proletaires£»¡¡to¡¡REGULATE¡¡PROPERTY£»¡¡that¡¡is£»¡¡you¡¡wish¡¡to¡¡destroy¡¡it¡¡and¡¡reduce¡¡it¡¡to¡¡the¡¡right¡¡of¡¡possession¡£¡¡¡¡For¡¡to¡¡regulate¡¡property¡¡without¡¡the¡¡consent¡¡of¡¡the¡¡proprietors¡¡is¡¡to¡¡deny¡¡the¡¡right¡¡OF¡¡DOMAIN£»¡¡to¡¡associate¡¡employees¡¡with¡¡proprietors¡¡is¡¡to¡¡destroy¡¡the¡¡EMINENT¡¡right£»¡¡to¡¡suppress¡¡or¡¡even¡¡reduce¡¡farm¡rent£»¡¡house¡rent£»¡¡revenue£»¡¡and¡¡increase¡¡generally£»¡¡is¡¡to¡¡annihilate¡¡PERFECT¡¡property¡£¡¡¡¡Why£»¡¡then£»¡¡while¡¡laboring¡¡with¡¡such¡¡laudable¡¡enthusiasm¡¡for¡¡the¡¡establishment¡¡of¡¡equality£»¡¡should¡¡you¡¡retain¡¡an¡¡expression¡¡whose¡¡equivocal¡¡meaning¡¡will¡¡always¡¡be¡¡an¡¡obstacle¡¡in¡¡the¡¡way¡¡of¡¡your¡¡success£¿
There¡¡you¡¡have¡¡the¡¡first¡¡reasona¡¡wholly¡¡philosophical¡¡onefor¡¡rejecting¡¡not¡¡only¡¡the¡¡thing£»¡¡but¡¡the¡¡name£»¡¡property¡£¡¡¡¡Here¡¡now¡¡is¡¡the¡¡political£»¡¡the¡¡highest¡¡reason¡£
Every¡¡social¡¡revolutionM¡£¡¡Cousin¡¡will¡¡tell¡¡youis¡¡effected¡¡only¡¡by¡¡the¡¡realization¡¡of¡¡an¡¡idea£»¡¡either¡¡political£»¡¡moral£»¡¡or¡¡religious¡£¡¡¡¡When¡¡Alexander¡¡conquered¡¡Asia£»¡¡his¡¡idea¡¡was¡¡to¡¡avenge¡¡Greek¡¡liberty¡¡against¡¡the¡¡insults¡¡of¡¡Oriental¡¡despotism£»¡¡when¡¡Marius¡¡and¡¡Caesar¡¡overthrew¡¡the¡¡Roman¡¡patricians£»¡¡their¡¡idea¡¡was¡¡to¡¡give¡¡bread¡¡to¡¡the¡¡people£»¡¡when¡¡Christianity¡¡revolutionized¡¡the¡¡world£»¡¡its¡¡idea¡¡was¡¡to¡¡emancipate¡¡mankind£»¡¡and¡¡to¡¡substitute¡¡the¡¡worship¡¡of¡¡one¡¡God¡¡for¡¡the¡¡deities¡¡of¡¡Epicurus¡¡and¡¡Homer£»¡¡when¡¡France¡¡rose¡¡in¡¡'89£»¡¡her¡¡idea¡¡was¡¡liberty¡¡and¡¡equality¡¡before¡¡the¡¡law¡£¡¡¡¡There¡¡has¡¡been¡¡no¡¡true¡¡revolution£»¡¡says¡¡M¡£¡¡Cousin£»¡¡with¡¡out¡¡its¡¡idea£»¡¡so¡¡that¡¡where¡¡an¡¡idea¡¡does¡¡not¡¡exist£»¡¡or¡¡even¡¡fails¡¡of¡¡a¡¡formal¡¡expression£»¡¡revolution¡¡is¡¡impossible¡£¡¡¡¡There¡¡are¡¡mobs£»¡¡conspirators£»¡¡rioters£»¡¡regicides¡£¡¡¡¡There¡¡are¡¡no¡¡revolutionists¡£¡¡¡¡Society£»¡¡devoid¡¡of¡¡ideas£»¡¡twists¡¡and¡¡tosses¡¡about£»¡¡and¡¡dies¡¡in¡¡the¡¡midst¡¡of¡¡its¡¡fruitless¡¡labor¡£
Nevertheless£»¡¡you¡¡all¡¡feel¡¡that¡¡a¡¡revolution¡¡is¡¡to¡¡come£»¡¡and¡¡that¡¡you¡¡alone¡¡can¡¡accomplish¡¡it¡£¡¡¡¡What£»¡¡then£»¡¡is¡¡the¡¡idea¡¡which¡¡governs¡¡you£»¡¡proletaires¡¡of¡¡the¡¡nineteenth¡¡century£¿for¡¡really¡¡I¡¡cannot¡¡call¡¡you¡¡revolutionists¡£¡¡¡¡What¡¡do¡¡you¡¡think£¿what¡¡do¡¡you¡¡believe£¿what¡¡do¡¡you¡¡want£¿¡¡¡¡Be¡¡guarded¡¡in¡¡your¡¡reply¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡have¡¡read¡¡faithfully¡¡your¡¡favorite¡¡journals£»¡¡your¡¡most¡¡esteemed¡¡authors¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡find¡¡everywhere¡¡only¡¡vain¡¡and¡¡puerile¡¡_entites_£»¡¡nowhere¡¡do¡¡I¡¡discover¡¡an¡¡idea¡£
I¡¡will¡¡explain¡¡the¡¡meaning¡¡of¡¡this¡¡word¡¡_entite_£»new£»¡¡without¡¡doubt£»¡¡to¡¡most¡¡of¡¡you¡£
By¡¡_entite_¡¡is¡¡generally¡¡understood¡¡a¡¡substance¡¡which¡¡the¡¡imagination¡¡grasps£»¡¡but¡¡which¡¡is¡¡incognizable¡¡by¡¡the¡¡senses¡¡and¡¡the¡¡reason¡£¡¡¡¡Thus¡¡the¡¡SOPORIFIC¡¡POWER¡¡of¡¡opium£»¡¡of¡¡which¡¡Sganarelle¡¡speaks£»¡¡and¡¡the¡¡PECCANT¡¡HUMORS¡¡of¡¡ancient¡¡medicine£»¡¡are¡¡_entites_¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡_entite_¡¡is¡¡the¡¡support¡¡of¡¡those¡¡who¡¡do¡¡not¡¡wish¡¡to¡¡confess¡¡their¡¡ignorance¡£¡¡¡¡It¡¡is¡¡incomprehensible£»¡¡or£»¡¡as¡¡St¡£¡¡Paul¡¡says£»¡¡the¡¡_argumentum¡¡non¡¡apparentium_¡£¡¡¡¡In¡¡philosophy£»¡¡the¡¡_entite_¡¡is¡¡often¡¡only¡¡a¡¡repetition¡¡of¡¡words¡¡which¡¡add¡¡nothing¡¡to¡¡the¡¡thought¡£
For¡¡example£»¡¡when¡¡M¡£¡¡Pierre¡¡Lerouxwho¡¡says¡¡so¡¡many¡¡excellent¡¡things£»¡¡but¡¡who¡¡is¡¡too¡¡fond£»¡¡in¡¡my¡¡opinion£»¡¡of¡¡his¡¡Platonic¡¡formulasassures¡¡us¡¡that¡¡the¡¡evils¡¡of¡¡humanity¡¡are¡¡due¡¡to¡¡our¡¡IGNORANCE¡¡OF¡¡LIFE£»¡¡M¡£¡¡Pierre¡¡Leroux¡¡utters¡¡an¡¡_entite£»_¡¡for¡¡it¡¡is¡¡evident¡¡that¡¡if¡¡we¡¡are¡¡evil¡¡it¡¡is¡¡because¡¡we¡¡do¡¡not¡¡know¡¡how¡¡to¡¡live£»¡¡but¡¡the¡¡knowledge¡¡of¡¡this¡¡fact¡¡is¡¡of¡¡no¡¡value¡¡to¡¡us¡£
When¡¡M¡£¡¡Edgar¡¡Quinet¡¡declares¡¡that¡¡France¡¡suffers¡¡and¡¡declines¡¡because¡¡there¡¡is¡¡an¡¡ANTAGONISM¡¡of¡¡men¡¡and¡¡of¡¡interests£»¡¡he¡¡declares¡¡an¡¡_entite£»_¡¡for¡¡the¡¡problem¡¡is¡¡to¡¡discover¡¡the¡¡cause¡¡of¡¡this¡¡antagonism¡£
When¡¡M¡£¡¡Lamennais£»¡¡in¡¡thunder¡¡tones£»¡¡preaches¡¡self¡sacrifice¡¡and¡¡love£»¡¡he¡¡proclaims¡¡two¡¡_entites_£»¡¡for¡¡we¡¡need¡¡to¡¡know¡¡on¡¡what¡¡conditions¡¡self¡sacrifice¡¡and¡¡love¡¡can¡¡spring¡¡up¡¡and¡¡exist¡£
So¡¡also£»¡¡proletaires£»¡¡when¡¡you¡¡talk¡¡of¡¡LIBERTY£»¡¡PROGRESS£»¡¡and¡¡THE¡¡SOVEREIGNTY¡¡OF¡¡THE¡¡PEOPLE£»¡¡you¡¡make¡¡of¡¡these¡¡naturally¡¡intelligible¡¡things¡¡so¡¡many¡¡_entites_¡¡in¡¡space£º¡¡for£»¡¡on¡¡the¡¡one¡¡hand£»¡¡we¡¡need¡¡a¡¡new¡¡definition¡¡of¡¡liberty£»¡¡since¡¡that¡¡of¡¡'89¡¡no¡¡longer¡¡suffices£»¡¡and£»¡¡on¡¡the¡¡other£»¡¡we¡¡must¡¡know¡¡in¡¡what¡¡direction¡¡society¡¡should¡¡proceed¡¡in¡¡order¡¡to¡¡be¡¡in¡¡progress¡£¡¡¡¡As¡¡for¡¡the¡¡sovereignty¡¡of¡¡the¡¡people£»¡¡that¡¡is¡¡a¡¡grosser¡¡_entite_¡¡than¡¡the¡¡sovereignty¡¡of¡¡reason£»¡¡it¡¡is¡¡the¡¡_entite_¡¡of¡¡_entites_¡£¡¡¡¡In¡¡fact£»¡¡since¡¡sovereignty¡¡can¡¡no¡¡more¡¡be¡¡conceived¡¡of¡¡outside¡¡of¡¡the¡¡people¡¡than¡¡outside¡¡of¡¡reason£»¡¡it¡¡remains¡¡to¡¡be¡¡ascertained¡¡who£»¡¡among¡¡the¡¡people£»¡¡shall¡¡exercise¡¡the¡¡sovereignty£»¡¡and£»¡¡among¡¡so¡¡many¡¡minds£»¡¡which¡¡shall¡¡be¡¡the¡¡sovereigns¡£¡¡¡¡To¡¡say¡¡that¡¡the¡¡people¡¡should¡¡elect¡¡their¡¡representatives¡¡is¡¡to¡¡say¡¡that¡¡the¡¡people¡¡should¡¡recognize¡¡their¡¡sovereigns£»¡¡which¡¡does¡¡not¡¡remove¡¡the¡¡difficulty¡¡at¡¡all¡£
But¡¡suppose¡¡that£»¡¡equal¡¡by¡¡birth£»¡¡equal¡¡before¡¡the¡¡law£»¡¡equal¡¡in¡¡personality£»¡¡equal¡¡in¡¡social¡¡functions£»¡¡you¡¡wish¡¡also¡¡to¡¡be¡¡equal¡¡in¡¡conditions¡£
Suppose¡¡that£»¡¡perceiving¡¡all¡¡the¡¡mutual¡¡relations¡¡of¡¡men£»¡¡whether¡¡they¡¡produce¡¡or¡¡exchange¡¡or¡¡consume£»¡¡to¡¡be¡¡relations¡¡of¡¡commutative¡¡justice£»in¡¡a¡¡word£»¡¡social¡¡relations£»¡¡suppose£»¡¡I¡¡say£»¡¡that£»¡¡perceiving¡¡this£»¡¡you¡¡wish¡¡to¡¡give¡¡this¡¡natural¡¡society¡¡a¡¡legal¡¡existence£»¡¡and¡¡to¡¡establish¡¡the¡¡f