eminent victorians-第5章

按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！



affectionately；　John　H。　Newman'。　But；　as　time　went　on；　the

situation　became　more　complicated。　Tractarianism　began　to　arouse

the　hostility；　not　only　of　the　evangelical；　but　of　the　moderate

churchmen；　who　could　not　help　perceiving　in　the　ever…deepening；

'catholicism'　of　the　Oxford　party；　the　dread　approaches　of　Rome。

The　〃Record〃　newspaper　an　influential　Evangelical　journal　took

up　the　matter　and　sniffed　Popery　in　every　direction；　it　spoke　of

certain　clergymen　as　'tainted'；　and　after　that；　preferment　seemed

to　pass　those　clergymen　by。　The　fact　that　Manning　found　it　wise

to　conduct　his　confessional　ministrations　in　secret　was　in　itself

highly　significant。　It　was　necessary　to　be　careful；　and　Manning

was　very　careful　indeed。　The　neighbouring　Archdeacon；　Mr。　Hare；

was　a　low　churchman；　Manning　made　friends　with　him；　as　warmly；　it

seemed；　as　he　had　made　friends　with　Newman。　He　corresponded　with

him；　asked　his　advice　about　the　books　he　should　read；　and

discussed　questions　of　Theology'As　to　Gal。　vi　15；　we　cannot

differ。。。。　With　a　man　who　reads　and　reasons　I　can　have　no

controversy；　and　you　do　both。'　Archdeacon　Hare　was　pleased；　but

soon　a　rumour　reached　him；　which　was；　to　say　the　least　of　it；

upsetting。　Manning　had　been　removing　the　high　pews　from　a　church

in　Brighton；　and　putting　in　open　benches　in　their　place。　Everyone

knew　what　that　meant；　everyone　knew　that　a　high　pew　was　one　of

the　bulwarks　of　Protestantism；　and　that　an　open　bench　had　upon　it

the　taint　of　Rome。　But　Manning　hastened　to　explain：　'My　dear

friend；'　he　wrote；　'I　did　not　exchange　pews　for　open　benches；　but

got　the　pews　（the　same　in　number）　moved　from　the　nave　of　the

church　to　the　walls　of　the　side　aisles；　so　that　the　whole　church

has　a　regular　arrangement　of　open　benches；　which　（irregularly）

existed　before　。。。　I　am　not　today　quite　well；　so　farewell；　with

much　regardYours　ever；　H。　E。　M。'　Archdeacon　Hare　was　reassured。



It　was　important　that　he　should　be；　for　the　Archdeacon　of

Chichester　was　growing　very　old；　and　Hare's　influence　might　be

exceedingly　useful　when　a　vacancy　occurred。　So；　indeed；　it　fell

out。　A　new　bishop；　Dr。　Shuttleworth；　was　appointed　to　the　See；

and　the　old　Archdeacon　took　the　opportunity　of　retiring。　Manning

was　obviously　marked　out　as　his　successor；　but　the　new　bishop

happened　to　be　a　low　churchman；　an　aggressive　low　churchman；　who

went　so　far　as　to　parody　the　Tractarian　fashion　of　using　Saints'

days　for　the　dating　of　letters　by　writing　'The　Palace；　washing…

day'；　at　the　beginning　of　his。　Andwhat　was　equally　serioushis

views　were　shared　by　Mrs。　Shuttleworth；　who　had　already　decided

that　the　pushing　young　Rector　was　'tainted'。　But　at　the　critical

moment　Archdeacon　Hare　came　to　the　rescue；　he　persuaded　the

Bishop　that　Manning　was　safe；　and　the　appointment　was　accordingly

madebehind　Mrs。　Shuttleworth's　back。　She　was　furious；　but　it

was　too　late；　Manning　was　an　Archdeacon。　All　the　lady　could　do；

to　indicate　her　disapprobation；　was　to　put　a　copy　of　Mr。

Bowdler's　book　in　a　conspicuous　position　on　the　drawing…room

table；　when　he　came　to　pay　his　respects　at　the　Palace。



Among　the　letters　of　congratulation　which　Manning　received；　was

one　from　Mr　Gladstone；　with　whom　he　had　remained　on　terms　of

close　friendship　since　their　days　together　at　Oxford。　'I

rejoice；'　Mr　Gladstone　wrote；　'on　your　account　personally；　but

more　for　the　sake　of　the　Church。　All　my　brothers…in…law　are　here

and　scarcely　less　delighted　than　I　am。　With　great　glee　am　I　about

to　write　your　new　address；　but；　the　occasion　really　calls　for

higher　sentiments；　and　sure　am　I　that　you　are　one　of　the　men　to

whom　it　is　specially　given　to　develop　the　solution　of　that　great

problemhow　all　our　minor　distractions　are　to　be　either

abandoned；　absorbed；　or　harmonised　through　the　might　of　the　great

principle　of　communion　in　the　body　of　Christ。'



Manning　was　an　Archdeacon；　but　he　was　not　yet　out　of　the　woods。

His　relations　with　the　Tractarians　had　leaked　out；　and　the　Record

was　beginning　to　be　suspicious。　If　Mrs。　Shuttleworth's　opinion　of

him　were　to　become　general；　it　would　certainly　be　a　grave　matter。

Nobody　could　wish　to　live　and　die　a　mere　Archdeacon。　And　then；　at

that　very　moment；　an　event　occurred　which　made　it　imperative　to

take　a　definite　step；　one　way　or　the　other。　That　event　was　the

publication　of　Tract　No。　90。



For　some　time　it　had　been　obvious　to　every　impartial　onlooker

that　Newman　was　slipping　down　an　inclined　plane　at　the　bottom　of

which　lay　one　thing；　and　one　thing　onlythe　Roman　Catholic

Church。　What　was　surprising　was　the　length　of　time　which　he　was

taking　to　reach　the　inevitable　destination。　Years　passed　before

he　came　to　realise　that　his　grandiose　edifice　of　a　Church

Universal　would　crumble　to　pieces　if　one　of　its　foundation　stones

was　to　be　an　amatory　intrigue　of　Henry　VIII。　But；　at　last　he

began　to　see　that　terrible　monarch　glowering　at　him　wherever　he

turned　his　eyes。　First　he　tried　to　exorcise　the　spectre　with　the

rolling　periods　of　the　Caroline　divines；　but　it　only　strutted　the

more　truculently。　Then　in　despair　he　plunged　into　the　writings　of

the　early　Fathers；　and　sought　to　discover　some　way　out　of　his

difficulties　in　the　complicated　labyrinth　of　ecclesiastical

history。　After　months　spent　in　the　study　of　the　Monophysite

heresy；　the　alarming　conclusion　began　to　force　itself　upon　him

that　the　Church　of　England　was　perhaps　in　schism。　Eventually　he

read　an　article　by　a　Roman　Catholic　on　St。　Augustine　and　the

Donatists；　which　seemed　to　put　the　matter　beyond　doubt。　St。

Augustine；　in　the　fifth　century；　had　pointed　out　that　the

Donatists　were　heretics　because　the　Bishop　of　Rome　had　said　so。

The　argument　was　crushing；　it　rang　in　Newman's　ears　for　days　and

nights；　and；　though　he　continued　to　linger　on　in　agony　for　six

years　more；　he　never　could　discover　any　reply　to　it。　All　he　could

hope　to　do　was　to　persuade　himself　and　anyone　else　who　liked　to

listen　to　him　that　the　holding　of　Anglican　orders　was　not

inconsistent　with　a　belief　in　the　whole　cycle　of　Roman　doctrine

as　laid　down　at　the　Council　of　Trent。　In　this　way　he　supposed

that　he　could　at　once　avoid　the　deadly　sin　of　heresy　and

conscientiously　remain　a　clergyman　in　the　Church　of　England；　and

with　this　end　in　view；　he　composed　Tract　No。　90。



The　object　of　the　Tract　was　to　prove　that　there　was　nothing　in

the　Thirty…nine　Articles　incompatible　with　the　creed　of　the　Roman

Church。　Newman　pointed　out；　for　instance；　that　it　was　generally

supposed　that　the　Articles　condemned　the　doctrine　of　Purgatory；

but　they　did　not；　they　merely　condemned　the　Romish　doctrine　of

Purgatory　and　Romish；　clearly；　was　not　the　same　thing　as　Roman。

Hence　it　followed　that　believers　in　the　Roman　doctrine　of

Purgatory　might　subscribe　the　Articles　with　a　good　conscience。

Similarly；　the　Articles　condemned　'the　sacrifices　of　masses'；　but

they　did　not　condemn　'the　sacrifice　of　the　Mass'。　Thus；　the　Mass

might　be　lawfully　celebrated　in　English　Churches。　Newman　took　the

trouble　to　examine　the　Articles　in　detail　from　this　point　of

view；　and　the　conclusion　he　came　to　in　every　case　supported　his

contention　in　a　singular　manner。



The　Tract　produced　an　immense　sensation；　for　it　seemed　to　be　a

deadly　and　treacherous　blow　aimed　at　the　very　heart　of　the　Church

of　England。　Deadly　it　certainly　was；　but　it　was　not　so

treacherous　as　it　appeared　at　first　sight。　The　members　of　the

English　Church　had　ingenuously　imagined　up　to　that　moment　that　it

was　possible　to　contain；　in　a　frame　of　words；　the　subtle　essence

of　their　complicated　doctrinal　system；　involving　the　mysteries　of

the　Eternal　and　the　Infinite　on　the　one　hand；　and　the　elaborate

adjustments　of　temporal　government　on　the　other。　They　did　not

understand　that　verbal　definitions　in　such　a　case　will　only

perform　their　functions　so　long　as　there　is　no　dispute　about　the

matters　which　they　are　intended　to　define：　that　is　to　say；　so

long　as　there　is　no　need　for　them。　For　generations　this　had　been

the　case　with　the　Thirty…nine　Articles。　Their　drift　was　clear

enough；　and　nobody　bothered　over　their　exact　meaning。　But

directly　someone　found　it　important　to　give　them　a　new　and

untraditional　interpretation；　it　appeared　that　they　were　a　mass

of　ambiguity；　and　might　be　twisted　into　meaning　very　nearly

anything　that　anybody　liked。　Steady…going　churchmen　were　appalled

and　outraged　when　they　saw　Newman；　in　Tract　No。　90；　performing

this　operation。　But；　after　all；　he　was　only　taking　the　Church　of

England　at　its　word。　And　indeed；　since　Newman　showed　the　way；　the

operation　has　become　so　exceedingly　common　that　the　most　steady…

going　churchman　hardly　raises　an　eyebrow　at　it　now。



At　the　time；　however；　Newman's　treatment　of　the　Articles　seemed

to　display　not　only　a　perverted　supersubtlety　of　intellect；　but　a

temper　of　mind　that　was　fundamentally　dishonest。　It　was　then　that

he　first　began　to　be　assailed　by　those　charges　of　untruthfulness

which　reached　their　culmination　more　than　twenty　years　later　in

the　celebrated　controversy　with　Charles　Kingsley；　which　led　to

the　writing　of　the　Apologia。　The　controversy　was　not　a　very

fruitful　one；　chiefly　because　Kingsley　could　no　more　understand

the　nature　of　Newman's　intelligence　than　a　subaltern　in　a　line

regiment　can　understand　a　Brahmin　of　Benares。　Kingsley　was　a

stout　Protestant；　whose　hatred　of　Popery　was；　at　bottom；　simply

ethicalan　honest；　instinctive　horror　of　the　practices　of

priestcraft　and　the　habits　of　superstition；　and　it　was　only

natural　that　he　should　see　in　those　innumerable　delicate

distinctions　which　Newman　was　perpetually　drawing；　and　which　he

himself　had　not　only　never　thought　of；　but　could　not　even　grasp；

simply　another　manifestation　of　the　inherent　falsehood　of　Rome。

But；　in　reality；　no　one；　in　one　sense　of　the　word；　was　more

truthful　than　Newman。　The　idea　of　deceit　would　have　been

abhorrent　to　him；　and　indeed　it　was　owing　to　his　very　desire　to

explain　what　he　had　in　his　mind　exactly　and　completely；　with　all

the　refinements　of　which　his　subtle　brain　was　capable；　that

persons　such　as　Kingsley　were　puzzled　into　thinking　him

dishonest。　Unfortunately；　however；　the　possibilities　of　truth　and

falsehood　depend　upon　other　things　besides　sincerity。　A　man　may

be　of　a　scrupulous　and　impeccable　honesty；　and　yet　his　respect

for　the　truth　it　cannot　be　denied　may　be　insufficient。　He　may

be；　like　the　lunatic；　the　lover；　and　the　poet；　'of　imagination

all　compact'；　he　may　be　blessed；　or　cursed；　with　one　of　those

'seething　brains'；　one　of　those　'shaping　fanatasies'　that

'apprehend　more　than　cool　reason　ever　comprehends'；　he　may　be　by

nature　incapable　of　sifting　evidence；　or　by　predilection　simply

indisposed　to　do　so。　'When　we　were　there；'　wrote　Newman　in　a

letter　to　a　friend　after　his　conversion；　describing　a　visit　to

Naples；　and　the　miraculous　circumstances　connected　with　the

liquefaction　of　St。　Januarius's　blood；　't