the crowd-第8章

按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！


ro　dear　to　crowds　will　always　have　the　semblance　of　a　Caesar。　　His　insignia　attracts　them；　his　authority　overawes　them；　and　his　sword　instils　them　with　fear。

A　crowd　is　always　ready　to　revolt　against　a　feeble；　and　to　bow　down　servilely　before　a　strong　authority。　　Should　the　strength　of　an　authority　be　intermittent；　the　crowd；　always　obedient　to　its　extreme　sentiments；　passes　alternately　from　anarchy　to　servitude；　and　from　servitude　to　anarchy。

However；　to　believe　in　the　predominance　among　crowds　of　revolutionary　instincts　would　be　to　entirely　misconstrue　their　psychology。　　It　is　merely　their　tendency　to　violence　that　deceives　us　on　this　point。　　Their　rebellious　and　destructive　outbursts　are　always　very　transitory。　　Crowds　are　too　much　governed　by　unconscious　considerations；　and　too　much　subject　in　consequence　to　secular　hereditary　influences　not　to　be　extremely　conservative。　　Abandoned　to　themselves；　they　soon　weary　of　disorder；　and　instinctively　turn　to　servitude。　　It　was　the　proudest　and　most　untractable　of　the　Jacobins　who　acclaimed　Bonaparte　with　greatest　energy　when　he　suppressed　all　liberty　and　made　his　hand　of　iron　severely　felt。

It　is　difficult　to　understand　history；　and　popular　revolutions　in　particular；　if　one　does　not　take　sufficiently　into　account　the　profoundly　conservative　instincts　of　crowds。　　They　may　be　desirous；　it　is　true；　of　changing　the　names　of　their　institutions；　and　to　obtain　these　changes　they　accomplish　at　times　even　violent　revolutions；　but　the　essence　of　these　institutions　is　too　much　the　expression　of　the　hereditary　needs　of　the　race　for　them　not　invariably　to　abide　by　it。　　Their　incessant　mobility　only　exerts　its　influence　on　quite　superficial　matters。　　In　fact　they　possess　conservative　instincts　as　indestructible　as　those　of　all　primitive　beings。　　Their　fetish…　like　respect　for　all　traditions　is　absolute；　their　unconscious　horror　of　all　novelty　capable　of　changing　the　essential　conditions　of　their　existence　is　very　deeply　rooted。　　Had　democracies　possessed　the　power　they　wield　to…day　at　the　time　of　the　invention　of　mechanical　looms　or　of　the　introduction　of　steam…power　and　of　railways；　the　realisation　of　these　inventions　would　have　been　impossible；　or　would　have　been　achieved　at　the　cost　of　revolutions　and　repeated　massacres。　　It　is　fortunate　for　the　progress　of　civilisation　that　the　power　of　crowds　only　began　to　exist　when　the　great　discoveries　of　science　and　industry　had　already　been　effected。


5。　THE　MORALITY　OF　CROWDS。


Taking　the　word　〃morality〃　to　mean　constant　respect　for　certain　social　conventions；　and　the　permanent　repression　of　selfish　impulses；　it　is　quite　evident　that　crowds　are　too　impulsive　and　too　mobile　to　be　moral。　　If；　however；　we　include　in　the　term　morality　the　transitory　display　of　certain　qualities　such　as　abnegation；　self…sacrifice；　disinterestedness；　devotion；　and　the　need　of　equity；　we　may　say；　on　the　contrary；　that　crowds　may　exhibit　at　times　a　very　lofty　morality。

The　few　psychologists　who　have　studied　crowds　have　only　considered　them　from　the　point　of　view　of　their　criminal　acts；　and　noticing　how　frequent　these　acts　are；　they　have　come　to　the　conclusion　that　the　moral　standard　of　crowds　is　very　low。

Doubtless　this　is　often　the　case；　but　why？　　Simply　because　our　savage；　destructive　instincts　are　the　inheritance　left　dormant　in　all　of　us　from　the　primitive　ages。　　In　the　life　of　the　isolated　individual　it　would　be　dangerous　for　him　to　gratify　these　instincts；　while　his　absorption　in　an　irresponsible　crowd；　in　which　in　consequence　he　is　assured　of　impunity；　gives　him　entire　liberty　to　follow　them。　　Being　unable；　in　the　ordinary　course　of　events；　to　exercise　these　destructive　instincts　on　our　fellow…　men；　we　confine　ourselves　to　exercising　them　on　animals。　　The　passion；　so　widespread；　for　the　chase　and　the　acts　of　ferocity　of　crowds　proceed　from　one　and　the　same　source。　　A　crowd　which　slowly　slaughters　a　defenceless　victim　displays　a　very　cowardly　ferocity；　but　for　the　philosopher　this　ferocity　is　very　closely　related　to　that　of　the　huntsmen　who　gather　in　dozens　for　the　pleasure　of　taking　part　in　the　pursuit　and　killing　of　a　luckless　stag　by　their　hounds。

A　crowd　may　be　guilty　of　murder；　incendiarism；　and　every　kind　of　crime；　but　it　is　also　capable　of　very　lofty　acts　of　devotion；　sacrifice；　and　disinterestedness；　of　acts　much　loftier　indeed　than　those　of　which　the　isolated　individual　is　capable。　　Appeals　to　sentiments　of　glory；　honour；　and　patriotism　are　particularly　likely　to　influence　the　individual　forming　part　of　a　crowd；　and　often　to　the　extent　of　obtaining　from　him　the　sacrifice　of　his　life。　　History　is　rich　in　examples　analogous　to　those　furnished　by　the　Crusaders　and　the　volunteers　of　1793。　　Collectivities　alone　are　capable　of　great　disinterestedness　and　great　devotion。　How　numerous　are　the　crowds　that　have　heroically　faced　death　for　beliefs；　ideas；　and　phrases　that　they　scarcely　understood！　　The　crowds　that　go　on　strike　do　so　far　more　in　obedience　to　an　order　than　to　obtain　an　increase　of　the　slender　salary　with　which　they　make　shift。　　Personal　interest　is　very　rarely　a　powerful　motive　force　with　crowds；　while　it　is　almost　the　exclusive　motive　of　the　conduct　of　the　isolated　individual。　　It　is　assuredly　not　self…interest　that　has　guided　crowds　in　so　many　wars；　incomprehensible　as　a　rule　to　their　intelligencewars　in　which　they　have　allowed　themselves　to　be　massacred　as　easily　as　the　larks　hypnotised　by　the　mirror　of　the　hunter。

Even　in　the　case　of　absolute　scoundrels　it　often　happens　that　the　mere　fact　of　their　being　in　a　crowd　endows　them　for　the　moment　with　very　strict　principles　of　morality。　　Taine　calls　attention　to　the　fact　that　the　perpetrators　of　the　September　massacres　deposited　on　the　table　of　the　committees　the　pocket…books　and　jewels　they　had　found　on　their　victims；　and　with　which　they　could　easily　have　been　able　to　make　away。　　The　howling；　swarming；　ragged　crowd　which　invaded　the　Tuileries　during　the　revolution　of　1848　did　not　lay　hands　on　any　of　the　objects　that　excited　its　astonishment；　and　one　of　which　would　have　meant　bread　for　many　days。

This　moralisation　of　the　individual　by　the　crowd　is　not　certainly　a　constant　rule；　but　it　is　a　rule　frequently　observed。　　It　is　even　observed　in　circumstances　much　less　grave　than　those　I　have　just　cited。　　I　have　remarked　that　in　the　theatre　a　crowd　exacts　from　the　hero　of　the　piece　exaggerated　virtues；　and　it　is　a　commonplace　observation　that　an　assembly；　even　though　composed　of　inferior　elements；　shows　itself　as　a　rule　very　prudish。　　The　debauchee；　the　souteneur；　the　rough　often　break　out　into　murmurs　at　a　slightly　risky　scene　or　expression；　though　they　be　very　harmless　in　comparison　with　their　customary　conversation。

If；　then；　crowds　often　abandon　themselves　to　low　instincts；　they　also　set　the　example　at　times　of　acts　of　lofty　morality。　　If　disinterestedness；　resignation；　and　absolute　devotion　to　a　real　or　chimerical　ideal　are　moral　virtues；　it　may　be　said　that　crowds　often　possess　these　virtues　to　a　degree　rarely　attained　by　the　wisest　philosophers。　　Doubtless　they　practice　them　unconsciously；　but　that　is　of　small　import。　　We　should　not　complain　too　much　that　crowds　are　more　especially　guided　by　unconscious　considerations　and　are　not　given　to　reasoning。　　Had　they；　in　certain　cases；　reasoned　and　consulted　their　immediate　interests；　it　is　possible　that　no　civilisation　would　have　grown　up　on　our　planet　and　humanity　would　have　had　no　history。



CHAPTER　III

THE　IDEAS；　REASONING　POWER；　AND　IMAGINATION　OF　CROWDS

1。　THE　IDEAS　OF　CROWDS。　　Fundamental　and　accessory　ideasHow　contradictory　ideas　may　exist　simultaneouslyThe　transformation　that　must　be　undergone　by　lofty　ideas　before　they　are　accessible　to　crowds　The　social　influence　of　ideas　is　independent　of　the　degree　of　truth　they　may　contain。　　　2。　THE　REASONING　POWER　OF　CROWDS。　　Crowds　are　not　to　be　influenced　by　reasoningThe　reasoning　of　crowds　is　always　of　a　very　inferior　orderThere　is　only　the　appearance　of　analogy　or　succession　in　the　ideas　they　associate。　　　3。　THE　IMAGINATION　OF　CROWDS。　Strength　of　the　imagination　of　crowdsCrowds　think　in　images；　and　these　images　succeed　each　other　without　any　connecting　linkCrowds　are　especially　impressed　by　the　marvellousLegends　and　the　marvellous　are　the　real　pillars　of　civilisationThe　popular　imagination　has　always　been　the　basis　of　the　power　of　statesmenThe　manner　in　which　facts　capable　of　striking　the　imagination　of　crowds　present　themselves　for　observation。


1。　THE　IDEAS　OF　CROWDS

WHEN　studying　in　a　preceding　work　the　part　played　by　ideas　in　the　evolution　of　nations；　we　showed　that　every　civilisation　is　the　outcome　of　a　small　number　of　fundamental　ideas　that　are　very　rarely　renewed。　　We　showed　how　these　ideas　are　implanted　in　the　minds　of　crowds；　with　what　difficulty　the　process　is　effected；　and　the　power　possessed　by　the　ideas　in　question　when　once　it　has　been　accomplished。　　Finally　we　saw　that　great　historical　perturbations　are　the　result；　as　a　rule；　of　changes　in　these　fundamental　ideas。

Having　treated　this　subject　at　sufficient　length；　I　shall　not　return　to　it　now；　but　shall　confine　myself　to　saying　a　few　words　on　the　subject　of　such　ideas　as　are　accessible　to　crowds；　and　of　the　forms　under　which　they　conceive　them。

They　may　be　divided　into　two　classes。　　In　one　we　shall　place　accidental　and　passing　ideas　created　by　the　influences　of　the　moment：　infatuation　for　an　individual　or　a　doctrine；　for　instance。　　In　the　other　will　be　classed　the　fundamental　ideas；　to　which　the　environment；　the　laws　of　heredity　and　public　opinion　give　a　very　great　stability；　such　ideas　are　the　religious　beliefs　of　the　past　and　the　social　and　democratic　ideas　of　to…day。

These　fundamental　ideas　resemble　the　volume　of　the　water　of　a　stream　slowly　pursuing　its　course；　the　transitory　ideas　are　like　the　small　waves；　for　ever　changing；　which　agitate　its　surface；　and　are　more　visible　than　the　progress　of　the　stream　itself　although　without　real　importance。

At　the　present　day　the　great　fundamental　ideas　which　were　the　mainstay　of　our　fathers　are　tottering　more　and　more。　　They　have　lost　all　solidity；　and　at　the　same　time　the　institutions　resting　upon　them　are　severely　shaken。　　Every　day　there　are　formed　a　great　many　of　those　transitory　minor　ideas　of　which　I　have　just　been　speaking；　but　very　few　of　them　to　all　appearance　seem　endowed　with　vitality　and　destined　to　acquire　a　preponderating　influence。

Whatever　be　the　ideas　suggested　to　crowds　they　can　only　exercise　effective　influence　on　condition　that　they　assume　a　very　absolute；　uncompromising；　and　simple　shape。　　They　present　themselves　then　in　the　guise　of　images；　and　are　only　accessible　to　the　masses　under　this　form。　　These　imagelike　ideas　are　not　connected　by　any　logical　bond　of　analogy　or　succession；　and　may　take　each　other's　place　like　the　slides　of　a　magic…lantern　which　the　operator　withdraws　from　the　groove　in　which　they　were　placed　one　above　the　other。　　This　explains　how　it　is　that　the　most　contradictory　ideas　may　be　seen　to　be　simultaneously　current　in　crowds。　　According　to　the　chances　of　the　moment；　a　crowd　will　come　under　the　influence　of　one　of　the　various　ideas　stored　up　in　its　understanding；　and　is　capable；　in　consequence；　of　committing　the　most　dissi