parmenides-µÚ3ÕÂ
°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡û »ò ¡ú ¿É¿ìËÙÉÏÏ·ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉ쵀 Enter ¼ü¿É»Øµ½±¾ÊéĿ¼ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡ü ¿É»Øµ½±¾Ò³¶¥²¿£¡
¡ª¡ª¡ª¡ªÎ´ÔĶÁÍꣿ¼ÓÈëÊéÇ©ÒѱãÏ´μÌÐøÔĶÁ£¡
difficulties¡¡in¡¡which¡¡we¡¡are¡¡involved¡¡if¡¡ideas¡¡really¡¡are¡¡and¡¡we
determine¡¡each¡¡one¡¡of¡¡them¡¡to¡¡be¡¡an¡¡absolute¡¡unity¡£¡¡He¡¡who¡¡hears
what¡¡may¡¡be¡¡said¡¡against¡¡them¡¡will¡¡deny¡¡the¡¡very¡¡existence¡¡of¡¡them¡and
even¡¡if¡¡they¡¡do¡¡exist£»¡¡he¡¡will¡¡say¡¡that¡¡they¡¡must¡¡of¡¡necessity¡¡be
unknown¡¡to¡¡man£»¡¡and¡¡he¡¡will¡¡seem¡¡to¡¡have¡¡reason¡¡on¡¡his¡¡side£»¡¡and¡¡as¡¡we
were¡¡remarking¡¡just¡¡now£»¡¡will¡¡be¡¡very¡¡difficult¡¡to¡¡convince£»¡¡a¡¡man
must¡¡be¡¡gifted¡¡with¡¡very¡¡considerable¡¡ability¡¡before¡¡he¡¡can¡¡learn¡¡that
everything¡¡has¡¡a¡¡class¡¡and¡¡an¡¡absolute¡¡essence£»¡¡and¡¡still¡¡more
remarkable¡¡will¡¡he¡¡be¡¡who¡¡discovers¡¡all¡¡these¡¡things¡¡for¡¡himself£»
and¡¡having¡¡thoroughly¡¡investigated¡¡them¡¡is¡¡able¡¡to¡¡teach¡¡them¡¡to
others¡£
¡¡¡¡I¡¡agree¡¡with¡¡you£»¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡said¡¡Socrates£»¡¡and¡¡what¡¡you¡¡say¡¡is
very¡¡much¡¡to¡¡my¡¡mind¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡yet£»¡¡Socrates£»¡¡said¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡if¡¡a¡¡man£»¡¡fixing¡¡his¡¡attention
on¡¡these¡¡and¡¡the¡¡like¡¡difficulties£»¡¡does¡¡away¡¡with¡¡ideas¡¡of¡¡things¡¡and
will¡¡not¡¡admit¡¡that¡¡every¡¡individual¡¡thing¡¡has¡¡its¡¡own¡¡determinate
idea¡¡which¡¡is¡¡always¡¡one¡¡and¡¡the¡¡same£»¡¡he¡¡will¡¡have¡¡nothing¡¡on¡¡which
his¡¡mind¡¡can¡¡rest£»¡¡and¡¡so¡¡he¡¡will¡¡utterly¡¡destroy¡¡the¡¡power¡¡of
reasoning£»¡¡as¡¡you¡¡seem¡¡to¡¡me¡¡to¡¡have¡¡particularly¡¡noted¡£
¡¡¡¡Very¡¡true£»¡¡he¡¡said¡£
¡¡¡¡But£»¡¡then£»¡¡what¡¡is¡¡to¡¡become¡¡of¡¡philosophy£¿¡¡Whither¡¡shall¡¡we¡¡turn£»
if¡¡the¡¡ideas¡¡are¡¡unknown£¿
¡¡¡¡I¡¡certainly¡¡do¡¡not¡¡see¡¡my¡¡way¡¡at¡¡present¡£
¡¡¡¡Yes£»¡¡said¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡and¡¡I¡¡think¡¡that¡¡this¡¡arises£»¡¡Socrates£»¡¡out¡¡of
your¡¡attempting¡¡to¡¡define¡¡the¡¡beautiful£»¡¡the¡¡just£»¡¡the¡¡good£»¡¡and¡¡the
ideas¡¡generally£»¡¡without¡¡sufficient¡¡previous¡¡training¡£¡¡I¡¡noticed
your¡¡deficiency£»¡¡when¡¡I¡¡heard¡¡you¡¡talking¡¡here¡¡with¡¡your¡¡friend
Aristoteles£»¡¡the¡¡day¡¡before¡¡yesterday¡£¡¡The¡¡impulse¡¡that¡¡carries¡¡you
towards¡¡philosophy¡¡is¡¡assuredly¡¡noble¡¡and¡¡divine£»¡¡but¡¡there¡¡is¡¡an
art¡¡which¡¡is¡¡called¡¡by¡¡the¡¡vulgar¡¡idle¡¡talking£»¡¡and¡¡which¡¡is¡¡of
imagined¡¡to¡¡be¡¡useless£»¡¡in¡¡that¡¡you¡¡must¡¡train¡¡and¡¡exercise
yourself£»¡¡now¡¡that¡¡you¡¡are¡¡young£»¡¡or¡¡truth¡¡will¡¡elude¡¡your¡¡grasp¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡what¡¡is¡¡the¡¡nature¡¡of¡¡this¡¡exercise£»¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡which¡¡you¡¡would
recommend£¿
¡¡¡¡That¡¡which¡¡you¡¡heard¡¡Zeno¡¡practising£»¡¡at¡¡the¡¡same¡¡time£»¡¡I¡¡give¡¡you
credit¡¡for¡¡saying¡¡to¡¡him¡¡that¡¡you¡¡did¡¡not¡¡care¡¡to¡¡examine¡¡the
perplexity¡¡in¡¡reference¡¡to¡¡visible¡¡things£»¡¡or¡¡to¡¡consider¡¡the¡¡question
that¡¡way£»¡¡but¡¡only¡¡in¡¡reference¡¡to¡¡objects¡¡of¡¡thought£»¡¡and¡¡to¡¡what¡¡may
be¡¡called¡¡ideas¡£
¡¡¡¡Why£»¡¡yes£»¡¡he¡¡said£»¡¡there¡¡appears¡¡to¡¡me¡¡to¡¡be¡¡no¡¡difficulty¡¡in
showing¡¡by¡¡this¡¡method¡¡that¡¡visible¡¡things¡¡are¡¡like¡¡and¡¡unlike¡¡and¡¡may
experience¡¡anything¡£
¡¡¡¡Quite¡¡true£»¡¡said¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡but¡¡I¡¡think¡¡that¡¡you¡¡should¡¡go¡¡a¡¡step
further£»¡¡and¡¡consider¡¡not¡¡only¡¡the¡¡consequences¡¡which¡¡flow¡¡from¡¡a
given¡¡hypothesis£»¡¡but¡¡also¡¡the¡¡consequences¡¡which¡¡flow¡¡from¡¡denying
the¡¡hypothesis£»¡¡and¡¡that¡¡will¡¡be¡¡still¡¡better¡¡training¡¡for¡¡you¡£
¡¡¡¡What¡¡do¡¡you¡¡mean£¿¡¡he¡¡said¡£
¡¡¡¡I¡¡mean£»¡¡for¡¡example£»¡¡that¡¡in¡¡the¡¡case¡¡of¡¡this¡¡very¡¡hypothesis¡¡of
Zeno's¡¡about¡¡the¡¡many£»¡¡you¡¡should¡¡inquire¡¡not¡¡only¡¡what¡¡will¡¡be¡¡the
consequences¡¡to¡¡the¡¡many¡¡in¡¡relation¡¡to¡¡themselves¡¡and¡¡to¡¡the¡¡one£»¡¡and
to¡¡the¡¡one¡¡in¡¡relation¡¡to¡¡itself¡¡and¡¡the¡¡many£»¡¡on¡¡the¡¡hypothesis¡¡of
the¡¡being¡¡of¡¡the¡¡many£»¡¡but¡¡also¡¡what¡¡will¡¡be¡¡the¡¡consequences¡¡to¡¡the
one¡¡and¡¡the¡¡many¡¡in¡¡their¡¡relation¡¡to¡¡themselves¡¡and¡¡to¡¡each¡¡other£»¡¡on
the¡¡opposite¡¡hypothesis¡£¡¡Or£»¡¡again£»¡¡if¡¡likeness¡¡is¡¡or¡¡is¡¡not£»¡¡what
will¡¡be¡¡the¡¡consequences¡¡in¡¡either¡¡of¡¡these¡¡cases¡¡to¡¡the¡¡subjects¡¡of
the¡¡hypothesis£»¡¡and¡¡to¡¡other¡¡things£»¡¡in¡¡relation¡¡both¡¡to¡¡themselves
and¡¡to¡¡one¡¡another£»¡¡and¡¡so¡¡of¡¡unlikeness£»¡¡and¡¡the¡¡same¡¡holds¡¡good¡¡of
motion¡¡and¡¡rest£»¡¡of¡¡generation¡¡and¡¡destruction£»¡¡and¡¡even¡¡of¡¡being
and¡¡not¡being¡£¡¡In¡¡a¡¡word£»¡¡when¡¡you¡¡suppose¡¡anything¡¡to¡¡be¡¡or¡¡not¡¡to
be£»¡¡or¡¡to¡¡be¡¡in¡¡any¡¡way¡¡affected£»¡¡you¡¡must¡¡look¡¡at¡¡the¡¡consequences¡¡in
relation¡¡to¡¡the¡¡thing¡¡itself£»¡¡and¡¡to¡¡any¡¡other¡¡things¡¡which¡¡you
choose¡to¡¡each¡¡of¡¡them¡¡singly£»¡¡to¡¡more¡¡than¡¡one£»¡¡and¡¡to¡¡all£»¡¡and¡¡so¡¡of
other¡¡things£»¡¡you¡¡must¡¡look¡¡at¡¡them¡¡in¡¡relation¡¡to¡¡themselves¡¡and¡¡to
anything¡¡else¡¡which¡¡you¡¡suppose¡¡either¡¡to¡¡be¡¡or¡¡not¡¡to¡¡be£»¡¡if¡¡you
would¡¡train¡¡yourself¡¡perfectly¡¡and¡¡see¡¡the¡¡real¡¡truth¡£
¡¡¡¡That£»¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡is¡¡a¡¡tremendous¡¡business¡¡of¡¡which¡¡you¡¡speak£»¡¡and¡¡I
do¡¡not¡¡quite¡¡understand¡¡you£»¡¡will¡¡you¡¡take¡¡some¡¡hypothesis¡¡and¡¡go
through¡¡the¡¡steps£¿¡then¡¡I¡¡shall¡¡apprehend¡¡you¡¡better¡£
¡¡¡¡That£»¡¡Socrates£»¡¡is¡¡a¡¡serious¡¡task¡¡to¡¡impose¡¡on¡¡a¡¡man¡¡of¡¡my¡¡years¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡will¡¡you£»¡¡Zeno£¿¡¡said¡¡Socrates¡£
¡¡¡¡Zeno¡¡answered¡¡with¡¡a¡¡smile£º¡Let¡¡us¡¡make¡¡our¡¡petition¡¡to¡¡Parmenides
himself£»¡¡who¡¡is¡¡quite¡¡right¡¡in¡¡saying¡¡that¡¡you¡¡are¡¡hardly¡¡aware¡¡of¡¡the
extent¡¡of¡¡the¡¡task¡¡which¡¡you¡¡are¡¡imposing¡¡on¡¡him£»¡¡and¡¡if¡¡there¡¡were
more¡¡of¡¡us¡¡I¡¡should¡¡not¡¡ask¡¡him£»¡¡for¡¡these¡¡are¡¡not¡¡subjects¡¡which
any¡¡one£»¡¡especially¡¡at¡¡his¡¡age£»¡¡can¡¡well¡¡speak¡¡of¡¡before¡¡a¡¡large
audience£»¡¡most¡¡people¡¡are¡¡not¡¡aware¡¡that¡¡this¡¡round¡about¡¡progress
through¡¡all¡¡things¡¡is¡¡the¡¡only¡¡way¡¡in¡¡which¡¡the¡¡mind¡¡can¡¡attain
truth¡¡and¡¡wisdom¡£¡¡And¡¡therefore£»¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡I¡¡join¡¡in¡¡the¡¡request
of¡¡Socrates£»¡¡that¡¡I¡¡may¡¡hear¡¡the¡¡process¡¡again¡¡which¡¡I¡¡have¡¡not
heard¡¡for¡¡a¡¡long¡¡time¡£
¡¡¡¡When¡¡Zeno¡¡had¡¡thus¡¡spoken£»¡¡Pythodorus£»¡¡according¡¡to¡¡Antiphon's
report¡¡of¡¡him£»¡¡said£»¡¡that¡¡he¡¡himself¡¡and¡¡Aristoteles¡¡and¡¡the¡¡whole
company¡¡entreated¡¡Parmenides¡¡to¡¡give¡¡an¡¡example¡¡of¡¡the¡¡process¡£¡¡I
cannot¡¡refuse£»¡¡said¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡and¡¡yet¡¡I¡¡feel¡¡rather¡¡like¡¡Ibycus£»
who£»¡¡when¡¡in¡¡his¡¡old¡¡age£»¡¡against¡¡his¡¡will£»¡¡he¡¡fell¡¡in¡¡love£»
compared¡¡himself¡¡to¡¡an¡¡old¡¡racehorse£»¡¡who¡¡was¡¡about¡¡to¡¡run¡¡in¡¡a
chariot¡¡race£»¡¡shaking¡¡with¡¡fear¡¡at¡¡the¡¡course¡¡he¡¡knew¡¡so¡¡well¡this¡¡was
his¡¡simile¡¡of¡¡himself¡£¡¡And¡¡I¡¡also¡¡experience¡¡a¡¡trembling¡¡when¡¡I
remember¡¡through¡¡what¡¡an¡¡ocean¡¡of¡¡words¡¡I¡¡have¡¡to¡¡wade¡¡at¡¡my¡¡time¡¡of
life¡£¡¡But¡¡I¡¡must¡¡indulge¡¡you£»¡¡as¡¡Zeno¡¡says¡¡that¡¡I¡¡ought£»¡¡and¡¡we¡¡are
alone¡£¡¡Where¡¡shall¡¡I¡¡begin£¿¡¡And¡¡what¡¡shall¡¡be¡¡our¡¡first¡¡hypothesis£»¡¡if
I¡¡am¡¡to¡¡attempt¡¡this¡¡laborious¡¡pastime£¿¡¡Shall¡¡I¡¡begin¡¡with¡¡myself£»¡¡and
take¡¡my¡¡own¡¡hypothesis¡¡the¡¡one£¿¡¡and¡¡consider¡¡the¡¡consequences¡¡which
follow¡¡on¡¡the¡¡supposition¡¡either¡¡of¡¡the¡¡being¡¡or¡¡of¡¡the¡¡not¡¡being¡¡of
one£¿
¡¡¡¡By¡¡all¡¡means£»¡¡said¡¡Zeno¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡who¡¡will¡¡answer¡¡me£¿¡¡he¡¡said¡£¡¡Shall¡¡I¡¡propose¡¡the¡¡youngest£¿¡¡He
will¡¡not¡¡make¡¡difficulties¡¡and¡¡will¡¡be¡¡the¡¡most¡¡likely¡¡to¡¡say¡¡what
he¡¡thinks£»¡¡and¡¡his¡¡answers¡¡will¡¡give¡¡me¡¡time¡¡to¡¡breathe¡£
¡¡¡¡I¡¡am¡¡the¡¡one¡¡whom¡¡you¡¡mean£»¡¡Parmenides£»¡¡said¡¡Aristoteles£»¡¡for¡¡I¡¡am
the¡¡youngest¡¡and¡¡at¡¡your¡¡service¡£¡¡Ask£»¡¡and¡¡I¡¡will¡¡answer¡£
¡¡¡¡Parmenides¡¡proceeded£º¡¡If¡¡one¡¡is£»¡¡he¡¡said£»¡¡the¡¡one¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡many£¿
¡¡¡¡Impossible¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡the¡¡one¡¡cannot¡¡have¡¡parts£»¡¡and¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡a¡¡whole£¿
¡¡¡¡Why¡¡not£¿
¡¡¡¡Because¡¡every¡¡part¡¡is¡¡part¡¡of¡¡a¡¡whole£»¡¡is¡¡it¡¡not£¿
¡¡¡¡Yes¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡what¡¡is¡¡a¡¡whole£¿¡¡would¡¡not¡¡that¡¡of¡¡which¡¡no¡¡part¡¡is¡¡wanting¡¡be¡¡a
whole£¿
¡¡¡¡Certainly¡£
¡¡¡¡Then£»¡¡in¡¡either¡¡case£»¡¡the¡¡one¡¡would¡¡be¡¡made¡¡up¡¡of¡¡parts£»¡¡both¡¡as
being¡¡a¡¡whole£»¡¡and¡¡also¡¡as¡¡having¡¡parts£¿
¡¡¡¡To¡¡be¡¡sure¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡in¡¡either¡¡case£»¡¡the¡¡one¡¡would¡¡be¡¡many£»¡¡and¡¡not¡¡one£¿
¡¡¡¡True¡£
¡¡¡¡But£»¡¡surely£»¡¡it¡¡ought¡¡to¡¡be¡¡one¡¡and¡¡not¡¡many£¿
¡¡¡¡It¡¡ought¡£
¡¡¡¡Then£»¡¡if¡¡the¡¡one¡¡is¡¡to¡¡remain¡¡one£»¡¡it¡¡will¡¡not¡¡be¡¡a¡¡whole£»¡¡and
will¡¡not¡¡have¡¡parts£¿
¡¡¡¡No¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡if¡¡it¡¡has¡¡no¡¡parts£»¡¡it¡¡will¡¡have¡¡neither¡¡beginning£»¡¡middle£»
nor¡¡end£»¡¡for¡¡these¡¡would¡¡of¡¡course¡¡be¡¡parts¡¡of¡¡it¡£
¡¡¡¡Right¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡then£»¡¡again£»¡¡a¡¡beginning¡¡and¡¡an¡¡end¡¡are¡¡the¡¡limits¡¡of
everything£¿
¡¡¡¡Certainly¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡the¡¡one£»¡¡having¡¡neither¡¡beginning¡¡nor¡¡end£»¡¡is¡¡unlimited£¿
¡¡¡¡Yes£»¡¡unlimited¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡therefore¡¡formless£»¡¡for¡¡it¡¡cannot¡¡partake¡¡either¡¡of¡¡round¡¡or
straight¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡why£¿
¡¡¡¡Why£»¡¡because¡¡the¡¡round¡¡is¡¡that¡¡of¡¡which¡¡all¡¡the¡¡extreme¡¡points¡¡are
equidistant¡¡from¡¡the¡¡centre£¿
¡¡¡¡Yes¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡the¡¡straight¡¡is¡¡that¡¡of¡¡which¡¡the¡¡centre¡¡intercepts¡¡the¡¡view
of¡¡the¡¡extremes£¿
¡¡¡¡True¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡the¡¡one¡¡would¡¡have¡¡parts¡¡and¡¡would¡¡be¡¡many£»¡¡if¡¡it¡¡partook
either¡¡of¡¡a¡¡straight¡¡or¡¡of¡¡a¡¡circular¡¡form£¿
¡¡¡¡Assuredly¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡having¡¡no¡¡parts£»¡¡it¡¡will¡¡be¡¡neither¡¡straight¡¡nor¡¡round£¿
¡¡¡¡Right¡£
¡¡¡¡And£»¡¡being¡¡of¡¡such¡¡a¡¡nature£»¡¡it¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡in¡¡any¡¡place£»¡¡for¡¡it
cannot¡¡be¡¡either¡¡in¡¡another¡¡or¡¡in¡¡itself¡£
¡¡¡¡How¡¡so£¿
¡¡¡¡Because¡¡if¡¡it¡¡were¡¡in¡¡another£»¡¡it¡¡would¡¡be¡¡encircled¡¡by¡¡that¡¡in
which¡¡it¡¡was£»¡¡and¡¡would¡¡touch¡¡it¡¡at¡¡many¡¡places¡¡and¡¡with¡¡many¡¡parts£»
but¡¡that¡¡which¡¡is¡¡one¡¡and¡¡indivisible£»¡¡and¡¡does¡¡not¡¡partake¡¡of¡¡a
circular¡¡nature£»¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡touched¡¡all¡¡round¡¡in¡¡many¡¡places¡£
¡¡¡¡Certainly¡¡not¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡if£»¡¡on¡¡the¡¡other¡¡hand£»¡¡one¡¡were¡¡in¡¡itself£»¡¡it¡¡would¡¡also¡¡be
contained¡¡by¡¡nothing¡¡else¡¡but¡¡itself£»¡¡that¡¡is¡¡to¡¡say£»¡¡if¡¡it¡¡were
really¡¡in¡¡itself£»¡¡for¡¡nothing¡¡can¡¡be¡¡in¡¡anything¡¡which¡¡does¡¡not
contain¡¡it¡£
¡¡¡¡Impossible¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡then£»¡¡that¡¡which¡¡contains¡¡must¡¡be¡¡other¡¡than¡¡that¡¡which¡¡is
contained£¿¡¡for¡¡the¡¡same¡¡whole¡¡cannot¡¡do¡¡and¡¡suffer¡¡both¡¡at¡¡once£»¡¡and
if¡¡so£»¡¡one¡¡will¡¡be¡¡no¡¡longer¡¡one£»¡¡but¡¡two£¿
¡¡¡¡True¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡one¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡anywhere£»¡¡either¡¡in¡¡itself¡¡or¡¡in¡¡another£¿
¡¡¡¡No¡£
¡¡¡¡Further¡¡consider£»¡¡whether¡¡that¡¡which¡¡is¡¡of¡¡such¡¡a¡¡nature¡¡can¡¡have
either¡¡rest¡¡or¡¡motion¡£
¡¡¡¡Why¡¡not£¿
¡¡¡¡Why£»¡¡because¡¡the¡¡one£»¡¡if¡¡it¡¡were¡¡moved£»¡¡would¡¡be¡¡either¡¡moved¡¡in
place¡¡or¡¡changed¡¡in¡¡nature£»¡¡for¡¡these¡¡are¡¡the¡¡only¡¡kinds¡¡of¡¡motion¡£
¡¡¡¡Yes¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡the¡¡one£»¡¡when¡¡it¡¡changes¡¡and¡¡ceases¡¡to¡¡be¡¡itself£»¡¡cannot¡¡be
any¡¡longer¡¡one¡£
¡¡¡¡It¡¡cannot¡£
¡¡¡¡It¡¡cannot¡¡therefore¡¡experience¡¡the¡¡sort¡¡of¡¡motion¡¡which¡¡is¡¡change¡¡of
nature£¿
¡¡¡¡Clearly¡¡not¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡can¡¡the¡¡motion¡¡of¡¡the¡¡one¡¡be¡¡in¡¡place£¿
¡¡¡¡Perhaps¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡if¡¡the¡¡one¡¡moved¡¡in¡¡place£»¡¡must¡¡it¡¡not¡¡either¡¡move¡¡round¡¡and
round¡¡in¡¡the¡¡same¡¡place£»¡¡or¡¡from¡¡one¡¡place¡¡to¡¡another£¿
¡¡¡¡It¡¡must¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡that¡¡which¡¡moves¡¡in¡¡a¡¡circle¡¡must¡¡rest¡¡upon¡¡a¡¡centre£»¡¡and¡¡that
which¡¡goes¡¡round¡¡upon¡¡a¡¡centre¡¡must¡¡have¡¡parts¡¡which¡¡are¡¡different
from¡¡the¡¡centre£»¡¡but¡¡that¡¡which¡¡has¡¡no¡¡centre¡¡and¡¡no¡¡parts¡¡cannot
possibly¡¡be¡¡carried¡¡round¡¡upon¡¡a¡¡centre£¿
¡¡¡¡Impossible¡£
¡¡¡¡But¡¡perhaps¡¡the¡¡motion¡¡of¡¡the¡¡one¡¡consists¡¡in¡¡change¡¡of¡¡place£¿
¡¡¡¡Perhaps¡¡so£»¡¡if¡¡it¡¡moves¡¡at¡¡all¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡have¡¡we¡¡not¡¡already¡¡shown¡¡that¡¡it¡¡cannot¡¡be¡¡in¡¡anything£¿
¡¡¡¡Yes¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡its¡¡coming¡¡into¡¡being¡¡in¡¡anything¡¡is¡¡still¡¡more¡¡impossible£»
is¡¡it¡¡not£¿
¡¡¡¡I¡¡do¡¡not¡¡see¡¡why¡£
¡¡¡¡Why£»¡¡because¡¡anything¡¡which¡¡comes¡¡into¡¡being¡¡in¡¡anything£»¡¡can
neither¡¡as¡¡yet¡¡be¡¡in¡¡that¡¡other¡¡thing¡¡while¡¡still¡¡coming¡¡into¡¡being£»
nor¡¡be¡¡altogether¡¡out¡¡of¡¡it£»¡¡if¡¡already¡¡coming¡¡into¡¡being¡¡in¡¡it¡£
¡¡¡¡Certainly¡¡not¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡therefore¡¡whatever¡¡comes¡¡into¡¡being¡¡in¡¡another¡¡must¡¡have
parts£»¡¡and¡¡then¡¡one¡¡part¡¡may¡¡be¡¡in£»¡¡and¡¡another¡¡part¡¡out¡¡of¡¡that
other£»¡¡but¡¡that¡¡which¡¡has¡¡no¡¡parts¡¡can¡¡never¡¡be¡¡at¡¡one¡¡and¡¡the¡¡same
time¡¡neither¡¡wholly¡¡within¡¡nor¡¡wholly¡¡without¡¡anything¡£
¡¡¡¡True¡£
¡¡¡¡And¡¡is¡¡there¡¡not¡¡a¡¡still¡¡greater¡¡impossibility¡¡in¡¡that¡¡which¡¡has
no¡¡parts£»¡¡and¡¡is¡¡not¡¡a¡¡whole£»¡¡coming¡¡into¡¡being¡¡anywhere£»¡¡since¡¡it
cannot¡¡come¡¡into¡¡being¡¡either¡¡as¡¡a¡¡part¡¡or¡¡as¡¡a¡¡whole£¿
¡¡¡¡Clearly¡£
¡¡¡¡Then¡¡it¡¡does¡¡not¡¡change¡¡place¡¡by¡¡revolving¡¡in¡¡the¡¡same¡¡spot£»¡¡not